The Journal

Concerns · 5 min read

Acne Marks vs Acne Scars: How to Fade Each

Dark marks and true scars need different treatments. How to tell them apart and what fades each one.

Acne Marks vs Acne Scars: How to Fade Each

Your breakouts have cleared, but the spots they left behind haven't. Most people call all of these "acne scars", but most of the time they aren't scars at all. They're marks, and marks fade with the right care. True scars change the texture of the skin and need professional treatment.

Knowing which one you have is the single most important step, because the treatments are completely different.

Three things people call acne scars

1. Dark marks (post-inflammatory hyperpigmentation)

Flat brown, dark brown or grey-black patches where a spot used to be. They happen when inflammation tells pigment cells to produce extra melanin. Dark marks are far more common and longer-lasting on medium to deeper skin tones, and they're the most common post-acne concern in South Africa.

How to tell: the skin is smooth when you run a finger over it. The colour is brown rather than red.

2. Red or pink marks (post-inflammatory erythema)

Flat red, pink or purplish marks, more common on fair skin. They're caused by small blood vessels that dilated and were damaged during the breakout.

How to tell: press a clear glass against the mark. If the colour fades under pressure, it's redness from blood vessels, not pigment.

3. True acne scars

These are changes in the skin's structure, where a deep breakout damaged or destroyed collagen.

  • Atrophic (indented) scars sit below the surface. Doctors divide them into ice-pick scars (narrow and deep), boxcar scars (wider with sharp edges) and rolling scars (soft dips that make skin look uneven).
  • Raised scars (hypertrophic scars and keloids) form when the skin makes too much collagen. Keloids are more common in deeper skin tones and on the jaw, chest and shoulders.

How to tell: you can feel the change. The skin dips or rises, and the texture stays visible even with make-up on.

How to fade dark marks

Dark marks almost always fade, but slowly. On deeper skin tones they can take 6 to 12 months or longer without treatment. The right routine shortens that a great deal.

Sunscreen comes first

UV and visible light keep dark marks dark. Without daily sunscreen, no brightening serum will work properly. Use a broad-spectrum SPF 50 every day; a tinted one adds visible-light protection. Our guide to tinted sunscreen for darker skin tones explains why.

Then use ingredients that slow pigment production

And gently speed up skin renewal

Exfoliating acids lift pigmented cells from the surface faster.

On medium to deeper skin, go gently. Over-exfoliating causes irritation, and irritation causes more dark marks.

How to fade red marks

Red marks usually fade on their own over a few months. You can help by:

  • Wearing sunscreen every day
  • Using calming ingredients such as niacinamide and azelaic acid
  • Avoiding harsh scrubs and very hot water
  • Leaving them alone. Picking keeps the inflammation going.

If red marks are still there after six months, vascular laser treatments in a clinic can target the blood vessels directly.

How true scars are treated

Indented scars are a structural problem, so no cream can fill them. What skincare can do is improve overall texture and tone, so scars look softer. Real improvement comes from in-clinic treatments that rebuild collagen:

  • Microneedling creates tiny controlled injuries that stimulate new collagen. It's suitable for most skin tones, including deeper ones. See our guide to aftercare after microneedling, peels or laser.
  • Chemical peels at medical strength improve shallow scarring and pigmentation at the same time.
  • Fractional laser resurfaces deeper scars but must be chosen carefully for darker skin, because some lasers can cause pigmentation.
  • Subcision and fillers release and lift rolling scars.

Most people need a course of several treatments, and combining treatments usually gives the best result. Raised scars and keloids should be treated by a doctor, as they need different approaches such as steroid injections.

A routine for post-acne marks

Morning

  1. Gentle cleanser
  2. Tri Vita C30 or another vitamin C serum
  3. Discoloration Defense
  4. SPF 50, tinted if possible

Evening

  1. Brightening Foam or another gentle cleanser
  2. Dual+ Anti-Blemish Serum if you're still breaking out, or Melan Tran3x Concentrate if you're not
  3. Light Ceutic two or three nights a week, building up slowly
  4. Moisturiser

The most important step: stop new marks forming

Every new breakout is a potential new mark. Treating active acne is the best long-term way to fade marks, especially on deeper skin. Our guide to adult and hormonal acne covers this in detail.

Not sure whether you're dealing with marks, scars or both? Book a consultation and we'll assess your skin and put together a plan, at home and in clinic.

FAQ

Frequently Asked Questions

How can I tell if I have an acne mark or an acne scar?+

Run your finger over it. If the skin is smooth and only the colour is different, it's a mark, and it will fade. If the skin dips below the surface or is raised, it's a true scar, which needs in-clinic treatment.

How long do dark marks from acne take to fade?+

Without treatment, dark marks can take 6 to 12 months or longer, especially on medium to deeper skin tones. Daily sunscreen and ingredients such as tranexamic acid, azelaic acid, vitamin C and niacinamide speed this up significantly.

Can a serum get rid of acne scars?+

No serum can fill an indented scar, because the damage is to the collagen underneath. Serums can improve texture and tone so scars look softer. Microneedling, peels and laser in a clinic are what rebuild collagen.

What's the best treatment for acne marks on dark skin?+

Start with daily SPF 50, ideally tinted. Then use tranexamic acid, azelaic acid, niacinamide or vitamin C, and exfoliate gently. Avoid anything that irritates the skin, because irritation can cause more pigmentation.

Why are my acne marks red instead of brown?+

Red or pink marks come from damaged blood vessels rather than pigment. They're more common on fair skin and usually fade on their own within a few months. Sunscreen and calming ingredients help them fade faster.